?

Log in

No account? Create an account

Journal of No. 118


March 19th, 2006

Three Books! Illiterates need not apply. @ 07:50 am

Tags:

Three recent finishes:

Tim Powers' Expiration Date: I had heard many people say that this and Earthquake Weather, which are pseudo-sequels to Last Call, were not very good. I think Last Call is Tim's best book, so I was mentally prepared for something not-as-good. This mental preparation probably helped me enjoy the book. It is nowhere near as good as Last Call, but still falls well above the mediocre line. I knew it was squirreled away somewhere in there, but it was still neat to see the reference to 'Donahue at Raleigh'. This seems to be a failure of an actual review. So just go read Last Call.

Brief Intervals of Horrible Sanity by Elizabeth Gold. The non-fictional story of a New York poet who gets tossed into a progressive school to teach English to urban hooligans. She comes in at the middle of the year as the 4th teacher in that classroom. The writing and poetic interludes are somewhat annoying, but it's still a good introduction to what's wrong with education today. And what is wrong, you ask? Everything. There's blame everywhere to go around. The kids, the teachers, the administration, the parents. The tone of the book dances between comedy and tragedy. The author is somewhat self-absorbed, but perhaps the most refreshing thing about the book is her openness in discussing her own shortcomings. Though, since she is so self-absorbed, I'm not sure she realizes that the picture she paints of herself shows a bad teacher. An interesting picture from the front lines - not bullshit from the school administration or the education authorities. On the whole, it's less entertaining than Azrael's stories of teaching English in Japan [thanks to marlo for reminding me of this guy. I caught up on a whole year of new stories.] So just go read about kancho.

The Man who was Thursday, by G.K. Chesterton: It's one of those books you hear about all the time, but never read. That's as it should be. Absolute bollocks. The first ten pages or so might be the start of an interesting suspense story, but the book rapidly spins out of control. After about 30 pages, all suspense evaporates, because you know exactly what's going to happen for the next few chapters. By the time you get through that, you know the general shape of the allegorical wrap up that must ensue. It's much less polemical than, say, CS Lewis' Screwtape Letters, but I see some similarities beyond the personal connections of the authors. Neither book is very diverting or very enjoyable, but they will stay in print forever because of the intellectual niche they inhabit. So just go read The 39 Steps; it's not very good either, but at least there's no bait-and-switch involved.
 
Share  |  Flag |

Comments

 
[User Picture Icon]
From:zorker
Date:March 19th, 2006 08:27 pm (UTC)
(Link)
I enjoyed Expiration Date, although I agree it is not as good as Last Call. But I will say that Earthquake Weather should be avoided at all costs. I hated the book. Couldn't even finish it. It tries to bring Last Call and Expiration Date together. Why? Why do these characters need to meet? Couldn't these books stand on their own? I have a copy if you're curious about reading it but not willing to gamble the cost of a paperback. Painful, though. Really just awful stuff.
[User Picture Icon]
From:essentialsaltes
Date:March 19th, 2006 08:47 pm (UTC)
(Link)
Thanks for the offer, but your recommendation leaves something to be desired! I've got a plenty long enough shelf of books to read as it is.

From:stevenkaye
Date:March 19th, 2006 09:31 pm (UTC)
(Link)
Declare, in my humble opinion, blows everything Powers has done previously out of the water. I can lend you my copy if you like.

I felt Last Call was flawed in its dealing (or rather, not dealing much) with the female protagonists. I also wanted more about the Archetypes.

But as an English major and lover of Francois Villon's work, I'm legally required to love The Stress of Her Regard, which Babbage Press is finally going to reprint.
[User Picture Icon]
From:essentialsaltes
Date:March 19th, 2006 11:16 pm (UTC)
(Link)
I liked Declare, but the milieu is not one that interests me that much. I read Stress long long ago, and it apparently didn't make much impression on me.
[User Picture Icon]
From:randbot
Date:March 20th, 2006 04:38 am (UTC)
(Link)
On Stranger Tides forever, baby!

I enjoyed On Stranger Tides, Anubis Gates and Last Call (in that order of preference), but I haven't been able to finish any of his books from Expiration Date onward.

From:(Anonymous)
Date:March 20th, 2006 07:16 am (UTC)
(Link)
Anubis Gates, mainly, then Expiration Date. Didn't like Last Call as much - I liked bits of it, but there were too many people I didn't care about at all in that book. Earthquake Weather was dreadful, dreadful, unless you'd enjoy a description of the Winchester Mystery House as ghost disposal device.

I will say that Tm Powers has some issues with guilt. Just sayin'.

-K-

Journal of No. 118